Lia Thomas controversy surrounds NCAA swimming championships, incites nationwide debate

WHEN LIA THOMAS’ fingertips break the floor of the water on Thursday on the McAuley Aquatic Heart in Atlanta, no one within the 500-yard freestyle, or in some other race on the NCAA ladies’s swimming and diving championships, may have navigated choppier waters.

Thomas, a transgender swimmer at Penn, has sparked searing skepticism together with her season-long dominance. Over the following 4 days, she’ll have three probabilities to turn out to be the primary identified transgender athlete to win an NCAA Division I nationwide championship.

Though she has adopted each eligibility rule and coverage set forth by the NCAA, Thomas has landed on the epicenter of debate — within the pool, within the media and in statehouses throughout the nation — about equity and inclusion and whether or not these values are mutually unique.

Thomas will not be the primary transgender athlete to compete in collegiate sports activities, nor the primary to achieve success. However nobody has spurred deeper division.

She may win, she may end on the rostrum, she won’t. However regardless of the end result, Thomas’ participation can be a victory for some and a defeat for others. Some will see it as progress and others will see it as regression. Some will cheer and a few will object. Everybody, it appears, already has taken a facet.

---

THOMAS’ LONG ARMS sliced by the water through the 200-yard freestyle at Ocasek Natatorium in Akron, Ohio, propelling her 6-foot-2 physique ahead. At every flip, her ft popped off the wall to kick-start her journey the opposite manner. This was the second day of a three-day meet, the final cease earlier than finals and winter break.

She already had received the 500 freestyle the day earlier than in snug vogue, posting one of the best time within the nation this season. Her time of Four minutes, 34.06 seconds trailed Katie Ledecky’s report by 10 seconds. Shut sufficient for eyebrows to boost. Thomas was undefeated in her particular person occasions to begin the season. As she pulled away from the sphere within the 200, it grew to become clear that this race could be extra of the identical.

When she touched the wall, her time flashed on the display screen: 1:41.93. It wasn’t simply quick; it was eye-popping. She now owned the nation’s prime time in two occasions and was two seconds off Missy Franklin’s NCAA report. And it was solely Dec. 4, 2021. The nationwide championships have been greater than three months away. Who knew how briskly she’d be by then?

As information of Thomas’ instances leaked out of Akron, it grew to become clear that her life was about to alter, that the NCAA swimming season was about to be upended.

The division began inside her personal workforce, some Penn swimmers expressed assist whereas others protested anonymously to the media. Barely a day handed with out Thomas’ identify within the information. As states similar to Indiana and Arizona thought of laws that may have an effect on transgender women’ capability to take part in women’ sports activities on the youth degree, Thomas was introduced up as the rationale why such legal guidelines have been wanted.

The controversy was pushed by the specter of Lia Thomas the swimmer, however little was identified about Lia Thomas the particular person.

---

THOMAS, WHO DECLINED a number of interview requests from ESPN, grew up in Austin, Texas, because the youngest of three youngsters. She’s been swimming since she was a toddler, following within the footsteps of her oldest brother, Wes. The 2 swam for Misplaced Creek Aquatics, and nonetheless maintain a number of membership information. Lia’s longest-standing report is within the 6-and-under division within the 100-yard backstroke.

Wes went to Penn and swam on the lads’s workforce, and Lia determined that is what she would do as properly, although they by no means overlapped in class. For 3 seasons, Lia swam on the Quakers males’s workforce. She was a distance specialist. However as she started school after graduating from Westlake Excessive College, she additionally struggled together with her id, based on a Sports Illustrated story. She acknowledged she was transgender and shared that together with her household following her freshman season in 2017-18. In her sophomore season, Thomas positioned second within the Ivy League championships within the 500, 1,000 and 1,650 freestyle occasions. Even with that athletic success, Thomas was struggling.

“I used to be very depressed,” Thomas informed Sports activities Illustrated. “I received to the purpose the place I could not go to high school. I used to be lacking lessons. My sleep schedule was tremendous tousled. Some days I could not get away from bed. I knew at that second I wanted to do one thing to deal with this.”

Thomas started hormone remedy in Could 2019, following her sophomore season. She continued to swim on the lads’s workforce as a junior, however sparingly. “It was a clumsy expertise being a girl competing in a males’s meet,” Thomas mentioned in a podcast with SwimSwam. “It was uncomfortable. So I did not compete that a lot.”

Thomas started swimming on the Penn ladies’s workforce within the fall of 2021. The Ivy League canceled all sports activities in 2020-21 because of the COVID-19 pandemic, so this season was Thomas’ first alternative to swim within the ladies’s class. At the start of the 2021 season, the NCAA coverage for transgender athletes was that transgender ladies have been eligible to compete within the ladies’s class after finishing 12 months of testosterone suppression. That coverage was enacted in 2011 and ruled all NCAA championships, although particular person colleges and conferences have been free to set their very own eligibility processes.

However Thomas’ instances in Akron introduced intense scrutiny not simply to herself, and never simply to her workforce, but additionally to the Penn, Ivy League and NCAA insurance policies. One media outlet revealed tabloid-style pictures of Thomas and her teammates whereas they have been coaching in Florida following winter break.

“It has been bizarre as a result of if I stand subsequent to Lia, then immediately my {photograph} emerges in some information outlet,” Penn teammate and fellow senior Andie Myers informed ESPN. “It is bizarre.”

Complaints from nameless teammates about shedding alternatives and sharing a locker room with Thomas surfaced in tales.

“I knew that there have been going to be folks that did not need Lia to swim or did not assume that it was honest, however I positively was not anticipating folks to be talking out like they have been,” sophomore Hadley DeBruyn informed ESPN. “I feel that that’s what shocked me essentially the most.”

The Penn swimmers’ opposing viewpoints have been expressed formally in dueling letters issued in February. On Feb. 1, an unsigned statement was issued by Penn athletics on behalf of “a number of members of the ladies’s swimming and diving workforce” that supported Thomas being a part of their workforce. Two days later, three-time Olympic gold medalist and Title IX advocate Nancy Hogshead-Makar despatched a letter to the Ivy League and its colleges’ presidents and athletic administrators on behalf of 16 anonymous Penn swimmers and their households, urging the Ivy League to not take authorized motion ought to the NCAA rule Thomas ineligible for the nationwide championships. And on Feb. 10, 310 members of the swimming group, together with representatives from every of the Energy 5 conferences and 5 of Thomas’ teammates, signed a letter to the NCAA organized by Athlete Ally and Harvard alum and transgender athlete Schuyler Bailar that expressed assist for Thomas.

Few members of the Penn ladies’s swimming and diving workforce have spoken on the report. Myers and DeBruyn are two of Thomas’ teammates who signed the letter organized by Bailar and Athlete Ally. Not one of the 16 swimmers who have been represented by Hogshead-Makar within the letter to the Ivy League have shared their identities publicly.

“We respect Lia as an individual. We respect her proper to stay as a girl and her proper to do no matter she feels is finest for herself in her life,” one Penn guardian who supported the Hogshead-Makar letter informed ESPN. “However on the identical time, that should not imply competing in opposition to the organic ladies and having the complete entry to the locker room.”

---

WHEN THOMAS JOINED the Penn ladies’s swimming workforce, the NCAA’s 2011 coverage on transgender participation already was beneath assessment. In October 2020, the NCAA hosted a summit on gender id and student-athlete participation. The acknowledged objective of the gathering was to “solicit suggestions towards the creation of a consensus framework which may inform coverage and observe improvement within the space of gender id and participation in collegiate sport…” It was one step in an arduous course of to reevaluate the group’s coverage that had been in operation for practically a decade.

“The entire level of it was to start the assessment strategy of the 2011 coverage,” mentioned LGBTQ sports activities inclusion advocate Pat Griffin, who labored on the primary coverage. “That course of was ongoing. After which, I feel, that the board of governors hijacked that course of by popping out and stunning everybody.”

On Jan. 19, 2022, the NCAA introduced it will undertake a sports-specific approach that may consider nationwide governing physique insurance policies and undertake them for NCAA eligibility. On the time, USA Swimming’s coverage for elite athletes deferred to the Worldwide Olympic Committee coverage, however that was additionally in flux as a result of an announcement in November 2021 that empowered every worldwide federation to create their very own insurance policies, although the IOC would supply steering.

“They failed ladies by not prioritizing equity.”

Nancy Hogshead-Makar

The NCAA announcement was met with condemnation and confusion by those that felt Thomas ought to be eligible to swim and by those that felt she ought to be ineligible.

“This replace complicates the NCAA coverage in a manner that I do not consider they’re outfitted to deal with,” duathlete and transgender inclusion advocate Chris Mosier mentioned on the time. “Provided that many [national governing bodies] haven’t created insurance policies for transgender athletes and that insurance policies fluctuate from sport NGB to NGB, monitoring compliance goes to be a nightmare for the NCAA. This creates many alternative requirements for trans athletes.”

Hogshead-Makar additionally expressed dismay. “The brand new NCAA coverage sounds quite a bit just like the previous one,” she mentioned. “The board hasn’t resolved the intractable balancing between equity, enjoying security and inclusion. They failed ladies by not prioritizing equity.”

For Ivy League executive director Robin Harris, the affect of Thomas’ success and a focus was obvious. “It is clear to me that the publicity and the success that Lia [Thomas] has been having elevated this situation on the NCAA,” Harris mentioned. “I do consider that the NCAA missed a chance to be a pacesetter, and as an alternative tried to keep away from having the NCAA coverage be the main focus of the eye, as a result of Lia has met the NCAA coverage that had been in existence for over a decade.”

On Feb. 1, USA Swimming shared a new policy governing eligibility for transgender swimmers. The coverage applies to USA Swimming members, designated elite occasions (which didn’t embrace the NCAA championships), and swimmers eager to be eligible for American information, which begins with the 13-14 age group. USA Swimming’s policy requires transgender ladies who need to compete within the ladies’s class to current proof that they haven’t any aggressive benefit to an impartial panel for assessment and to take care of a testosterone degree under 5 nanomoles per liter for 36 consecutive months. That degree is considerably under the earlier customary of 10 nanomoles per liter utilized by the IOC till November, and the time required to show the decrease degree is tripled.

If the NCAA adopted these guidelines for the 2022 winter championships — because the Jan. 19 announcement opened the door for — it will have been not possible for Thomas to compete for a nationwide championship. Thomas has mentioned she started hormone remedy in Could 2019, or 34 months previous to the 2022 NCAA championships.

However on Feb. 10, the NCAA introduced that it will not adopt the new USA Swimming standards for the 2022 ladies’s swimming and diving championships. As an alternative, transgender athletes compliant with the earlier customary would wish to submit a one-time check exhibiting a testosterone degree under 10 nanomoles per liter. The announcement cleared the way in which for Thomas to take part this week in Atlanta, the place she is scheduled to compete within the 100, 200 and 500-yard freestyle.

“There’s a sense, significantly the Ivy League swimmers and the Ivy League households, that they have been deserted,” Hogshead-Makar mentioned. “That no one’s standing up for them, that the game leaders didn’t get their act collectively earlier than Lia got here alongside. And I agree with them.”

---

WHEN IT COMES to disagreements about whether or not or not Thomas — and different transgender ladies — ought to be allowed to compete within the ladies’s class, the query is usually posed as one in all equity. However it is usually about id, intercourse and what the phrase “lady” means.

“There are two philosophies which are clashing proper now,” Hogshead-Makar mentioned. “One is an ideology of gender id and the opposite one is the thought of science and biology. The ideology is trans ladies are ladies. For essentially the most half, folks have been onboard for the thought that you really want transgender folks to be welcome in employment and public lodging. However then there’s the biology a part of it in relation to medical remedy, or ladies’s sports activities. That ideology will not be reality. It’s not a undeniable fact that trans ladies are ladies.”

The science of transgender athletes is an evolving area, however there are some things which are identified: testosterone is, on common, many instances increased in these assigned male at delivery in comparison with these assigned feminine at delivery; testosterone confers physiological and metabolic benefits similar to elevated muscle mass, lung capability, elevated top, and so on.; testosterone suppression successfully reduces ranges in transgender ladies to be on par with these of cisgender ladies after roughly one 12 months.

“We all know that testosterone will not be at all times immediately reflective of athletic efficiency, though it definitely might play a job in some athletic endeavors,” mentioned pediatric endocrinologist Jason Klein, who works with youngsters, adolescents and younger adults in his place at NYU Langone Well being.

There have been some research that look at the results of hormone remedy on athletic efficiency and physiological retention of energy. The primary, which was carried out by Joanna Harper and revealed in 2015, adopted a handful of transgender ladies distance runners. Harper’s examine — which she emphasised was a small examine — discovered that transgender ladies, after a 12 months of hormone remedy, did not enhance post-transition. In the event that they ranked, say, 15th in opposition to the lads, then they ranked 15th amongst ladies. Regardless of its measurement, Harper’s examine was the primary of its type and supplied a baseline for coverage frameworks.

Harper additionally revealed a assessment of the prevailing literature on the subject in 2021. She discovered that whereas hemoglobin ranges — or purple blood cells carrying oxygen to muscle tissues — in transgender ladies decreased with hormone remedy, there was nonetheless energy retention after 36 months of hormone remedy. This was consistent with a examine revealed in 2019 that evaluated the extent of muscle mass misplaced in transgender ladies after one 12 months of hormone remedy, which discovered that transgender ladies misplaced simply 5%.

Of these research, solely Harper’s on distance runners measured leads to transgender athletes. Additionally they all targeted on transgender adults, usually those that transitioned after puberty.

The following closest examine to look at outcomes of transgender athletes was completed by Christina Roberts, who analyzed out there information on transgender members of the navy performing situps, pushups and 1.5-mile runs at varied levels of hormone remedy. The outcomes confirmed that inside two years, the efficiency hole between transgender ladies and cisgender ladies on pushups and situps disappeared. For the 1.5-mile run, transgender ladies declined in velocity, however nonetheless exceeded the efficiency ranges of cisgender ladies. “I feel it exhibits that statements that, ‘Oh no, the trans ladies won’t ever come right down to the extent of cis ladies,’ is simply not true,'” Roberts mentioned.

“Now, are there some retained anatomic variations? Your common one who’s assigned male at delivery is taller than your cis feminine. And so the place having narrower hips and longer limbs is a bonus, yeah there’s some retained anatomic benefit. Then again, we’re not banning tall slender-hipped ladies. Anatomic benefit is an underlying reality in sport.”

For Thomas, there may be information out there for her previous to and after transition. For individuals who argue she should not be eligible to swim within the ladies’s class, the distinction in her relative efficiency as expressed in that information is essential. Within the 200 free, Thomas had the 465th quickest time previous to transition. She is at the moment the quickest in that occasion. Within the 500 free, she was 65th; she’s at the moment first. Within the 1,650, beforehand her finest occasion, Thomas’ highest rating was 32nd. She has the 11th finest time in that occasion regardless of not swimming it since December.

“She remains to be virtually undoubtedly higher as a feminine swimmer than she ever would have been as a male swimmer,” Harper mentioned. “[But] the notion that every one trans ladies can be higher within the ladies’s class than they have been within the males’s class is flawed. I’ve seen trans ladies who had bother adapting to the altering hormone ranges and/or their meds. These ladies find yourself worse in comparison with ladies than they have been in comparison with males. After all, nobody will ever hear of those trans ladies as a result of they are not profitable in ladies’s sport.”

Thomas’ finest instances whereas competing on the lads’s workforce have been 1:39.31 within the 200 free, 4:18.72 within the 500 and 14:54.76 within the 1,650. Thomas’ finest instances whereas competing on the ladies’s workforce to this point have been 1:41.93 within the 200, 4:34.06 within the 500 and 15:59.71 within the 1,650.

All three of her prime instances this season got here on the Zippy Invitational in early December in Akron. It wasn’t till the Ivy League championships that Thomas posted her prime time within the 100.

---

HARVARD’S BLODGETT POOL, web site of the 2022 Ivy League ladies’s swimming and diving championships, felt like a sauna final month. The warmth bubbled by the room cramped with spectators cheering on the ladies from the eight colleges of the convention competing within the pool.

Thomas walked out to the blocks for the ultimate within the 100 freestyle, passing beneath a transgender flag draped over the railing by Bailar, who had come to the meet to assist her, in addition to one other transgender athlete from Yale, Iszac Henig. Henig, a transgender man, swam on the ladies’s workforce and was competing in opposition to Thomas on this race. Henig landed within the highlight after beating Thomas at a meet in January.

“I feel that persons are entitled to their opinions, proper, however these opinions are additionally hurtful,” Henig informed ESPN after the race in January. “It is exhausting to see sports activities getting used as an excuse to be hateful to folks. As a result of I feel that, the truth that I used to be roped into a few of these nasty articles, regardless of ‘doing all the pieces proper’ by competing with the gender that I used to be assigned at delivery. It is not about equity, while you actually break it down.”

Bailar introduced the flag to Blodgett as a result of he remembered his personal last meet at Harvard. A few of his social media followers introduced a transgender flag and waved it within the stands. “Each time I noticed it within the stands, I discovered myself in tears as a result of it was so stunning to see that reminder of our personal resilience as trans folks,” Bailar mentioned. “The world has seen a whole lot of hatred and vitriol in opposition to Lia and in opposition to trans athletes normally. Having a record-breaking variety of anti-trans athlete payments within the nation in 2021 and 2022, there’s a whole lot of damaging power surrounding us. And that is really not complete of what exists. There’s way more assist than I feel the media is giving credit score for.”

On the sound of the horn, Thomas and Henig dove into the pool. Henig was defending the pool report he’d set within the prelims and Thomas seemed to avenge her loss to Henig earlier within the season. On the last flip, they began residence neck and neck. Nevertheless it was Thomas who out touched Henig on the wall, setting a meet and pool report within the course of. It was her third particular person convention championship, which might propel her to win the award for prime level scorer of the meet.

Thomas embraced Henig in celebration and pointed her index finger to the sky.

“Swimming is much extra in regards to the racing than it’s about successful,” Henig mentioned. “And, certain, successful is enjoyable, however on the finish of the day, I made myself proud. I made my teammates proud. I made my coaches proud, and that is what issues to me.”

Beneath the celebratory moments within the pool, nonetheless, was the information that not everybody was proud of Thomas’ presence, whilst they applauded politely when Thomas accepted her trophies and medals.

“I might identical to folks to know that supporting trans folks does imply you need to assist them in sports activities as properly.”

Penn swimmer Andie Myers

A lady who recognized herself solely because the mom of an Ivy League swimmer learn an account of her and her daughter’s experiences that was posted on the Women’s Declaration International YouTube channel. “The enjoyment of the meet was spoiled from the onset however we could not convey ourselves to let our women face this alone,” she mentioned of her expertise at Blodgett. “Day after day we watched as a younger girl was changed in a last swim, changed on the rostrum, erased from a report or relay spot, and eventually changed by swimmer of the meet by a person.”

An nameless Penn swimmer spoke to NewsNation following the meet. “I have been discriminated in opposition to and my teammates have too,” she mentioned. “The NCAA has allowed it to occur and it is shameful.”

Almost all Ivy League swimmers and coaches who obtained requests declined to be interviewed for this story, together with each member and coach of the Penn ladies’s swimming and diving workforce, apart from DeBruyn and Myers. One different Penn swimmer agreed to be interviewed, however declined to reply questions on Thomas.

Watching Thomas swim from off to the facet was Myers. She wore a transgender flag face masks the complete meet to publicly declare her assist for Thomas. “There’s lots of people who assume they assist trans folks however begin to attract the road in relation to sports activities,” Myers mentioned. “There are nuances, however I feel a whole lot of that will get misplaced and I feel lots of people find yourself utilizing transphobic arguments in opposition to her competing. So I might identical to folks to know that supporting trans folks does imply you need to assist them in sports activities as properly.”

That stress roiling in Blodgett was already spilling throughout the nation, and Thomas was nonetheless on the heart.

---

STANDING BEHIND A picket lectern within the Senate chamber on the Indiana state capitol in Indianapolis, Jackie Stein, the mom of two daughters who compete in swimming, argued the case for why pending invoice HB 1041 ought to cross. “This situation could be very seen proper now within the swimming group because of the media protection following College of Pennsylvania competitor Lia Thomas,” Stein mentioned. She went on to cite Hogshead-Makar arguing that Thomas had an unfair benefit as motive to cross HB 1041 in Indiana, which might prohibit transgender women from taking part in women’ sports activities.

HB 1041 is only one instance of legislation filed across the country that impacts transgender youth. As of this writing, there are payments limiting athletic participation for transgender youth filed in 25 states, based on the ACLU, which tracks such laws. Eleven states have already signed comparable laws into regulation. There are payments affecting entry to healthcare for transgender youth filed in 17 states. There are payments limiting single-sex amenities — generally known as “rest room payments” — filed in 4 states.

“It is predictably terrible,” Mosier mentioned. Mosier was driving again to his residence in Chicago from a rally in St. Paul, Minnesota, the place a invoice was filed that may prohibit transgender women from taking part in women’ sports activities on the center and highschool ranges. Mosier left his residence at 6 a.m. to drive the six hours to the Minnesota capital, arriving 10 minutes earlier than he was supposed to talk. He stood on the steps in entrance of the stone-faced constructing, the identical web site of the 2012 victory rally following the state’s historic defeat of a constitutional modification that may have banned marriage equality. After a couple of pleasantries, Mosier hopped again in his automobile to drive residence. It was practically darkish once more when he known as.

“We’re seeing the escalation of assaults on the trans group in a manner that has morphed from final 12 months in what I take into account to be a predictable manner,” Mosier mentioned. He pointed to the language utilized in some payments filed in 2020 and 2021 that targeted on exams to show intercourse. The unique textual content of Idaho’s HB 500, for instance, acknowledged that if an individual’s intercourse was disputed, a signed doctor assertion confirming “The coed’s inner and exterior reproductive anatomy; The coed’s regular endogenously produced ranges of testosterone; An evaluation of the scholar’s genetic make-up” to show intercourse. Advocates characterised such necessities as tantamount to “genital inspections,” moderately than routine exams as proponents argued.

“While you go that excessive, something lower than that appears extra cheap,” Mosier mentioned.

Many payments filed within the 2022 session moved away from that language in favor of utilizing “official delivery certificates” — learn: not amended — because the delineation of intercourse. This method mirrored Texas’ regulation that handed in October 2021. South Dakota and Iowa enacted legal guidelines this session utilizing that language. Pending payments in Indiana and Arizona used it as properly.

Although Thomas’ identify has been invoked in Indiana, Arizona, and elsewhere, lots of the payments and legal guidelines which have handed have an effect on not simply collegiate athletes, however youth enjoying college sports activities, typically as younger as elementary college.

“Typically, after we’re speaking about enjoying sports activities, certain what involves our thoughts’s eye are the professionals,” mentioned Olympic swimmer Casey Legler, who helps Thomas’ eligibility. “That’s not sports activities. Sports activities is your native membership. Sports activities is the pickup recreation that is being performed within the park. Sports activities is the man who will not be good at lifting weights and who nonetheless goes to the fitness center, as a result of it makes them really feel higher. That’s really most individuals’s expertise of sports activities.”

Georgia, the place Thomas will race this week, is a type of states with a pending invoice. And when she dives into the pool at Georgia Tech, all eyes can be on her. She may win, she may end on the rostrum, she won’t. However she can be swimming. Simply as she has all season.