The Vacuum Tube’s Forgotten Rival

Through the Second World Struggle, the German navy developed what had been on the time some very refined applied sciences, together with the
V-2 rockets it used to rain destruction on London. But the V-2, together with a lot different German navy {hardware}, relied on an obscure and seemingly antiquated part you’ve in all probability by no means heard of, one thing known as the magnetic amplifier or magazine amp.

In the USA, magazine amps had lengthy been thought-about out of date—“too sluggish, cumbersome, and inefficient to be taken severely,” in line with one supply. So U.S. military-electronics consultants of that period had been baffled by the in depth German use of this system, which they first discovered about from interrogating German prisoners of battle. What did the Third Reich’s engineers know that had eluded the Individuals?

---

After the battle, U.S. intelligence officers scoured Germany for helpful scientific and technical info. 4 hundred consultants sifted by billions of pages of paperwork and shipped 3.5 million microfilmed pages again to the USA, together with virtually 200 tonnes of German industrial tools. Amongst this mass of data and tools was the key of Germany’s magnetic amplifiers: metallic alloys that made these gadgets compact, environment friendly, and dependable.

U.S. engineers had been quickly in a position to reproduce these alloys. In consequence, the 1950s and ’60s noticed a renaissance for magnetic amplifiers, throughout which they had been used extensively within the navy, aerospace, and different industries. They even appeared in some early solid-state digital computer systems earlier than giving manner fully to transistors. These days, that historical past is all however forgotten. So right here I’ll supply the little-known story of the magazine amp.

An amplifier, by
definition, is a tool that enables a small sign to regulate a bigger one. An old style triode vacuum tube does that utilizing a voltage utilized to its grid electrode. A contemporary field-effect transistor does it utilizing a voltage utilized to its gate. The magazine amp workouts management electromagnetically.

To grasp the way it works, first contemplate a easy inductor, say, a wire coiled round an iron rod. Such an inductor will have a tendency to dam the circulation of alternating present by the wire. That’s as a result of when present flows, the coil creates an alternating magnetic subject, concentrated within the iron rod. And that various magnetic subject induces voltages within the wire that act to oppose the alternating present that created the sphere within the first place.

If such an inductor carries lots of present, the rod can attain a state known as saturation, whereby the iron can not develop into any extra magnetized than it already is. When that occurs, present passes by the coil nearly unimpeded. Saturation is often undesirable, however the magazine amp exploits this impact.

Bodily, a magnetic amplifier is constructed round a metallic core of fabric that may simply be saturated, usually a hoop or sq. loop with a wire wrapped round it. A second wire additionally wrapped across the core types a management winding. The management winding contains many turns of wire, so by passing a comparatively small direct present by it, the iron core may be compelled into or out of saturation.

The magazine amp thus behaves like a swap: When saturated, it lets the AC present in its principal winding move unimpeded; when unsaturated, it blocks that present. Amplification happens as a result of a comparatively small DC management present can modify a a lot bigger AC load present.

The historical past of magnetic amplifiers begins in the USA with some patents filed in 1901. By 1916, giant magnetic amplifiers had been getting used for transatlantic radio telephony, carried out with an invention known as an
Alexanderson alternator, which produced a high-power, high-frequency alternating present for the radio transmitter. A magnetic amplifier modulated the output of the transmitter in line with the power of the voice sign to be transmitted.

One Navy coaching handbook of 1951 defined magnetic amplifiers intimately—though with a defensive angle about their historical past.

Within the 1920s, enhancements in vacuum tubes made this mixture of Alexanderson alternator and magnetic amplifier out of date. This left the magnetic amplifier to play solely minor roles, similar to for gentle dimmers in theaters.

Germany’s later successes with magnetic amplifiers hinged largely on the event of superior magnetic alloys. A magnetic amplifier constructed from these supplies switched sharply between the on and off states, offering higher management and effectivity. These supplies had been, nevertheless, exquisitely delicate to impurities, variations in crystal dimension and orientation, and even mechanical stress. So that they required an exacting manufacturing course of.

The very best-performing German materials, developed in 1943, was known as Permenorm 5000-Z. It was an especially pure fifty/fifty nickel-iron alloy, melted beneath a partial vacuum. The metallic was then cold-rolled as skinny as paper and wound round a nonmagnetic kind. The outcome resembled a roll of tape, with skinny Permenorm metallic making up the tape. After winding, the module was annealed in hydrogen at 1,100 °C for two hours after which quickly cooled. This course of oriented the metallic crystals in order that they behaved like one giant crystal with uniform properties. Solely after this was carried out had been wires wrapped across the core.

By 1948, scientists on the U.S.
Naval Ordnance Laboratory, in Maryland, had found out the way to manufacture this alloy, which was quickly marketed by an outfit called Arnold Engineering Co. beneath the title Deltamax. The arrival of this magnetic materials in the USA led to renewed enthusiasm for magnetic amplifiers, which tolerated excessive circumstances and didn’t burn out like vacuum tubes. Magazine amps thus discovered many functions in demanding environments, particularly navy, area, and industrial management.

Through the 1950s, the U.S. navy was utilizing magnetic amplifiers in automated pilots, fire-control equipment, servo programs, radar and sonar tools, the
RIM-2 Terrier surface-to-air missile, and plenty of different roles. One Navy training manual of 1951 defined magnetic amplifiers intimately—though with a defensive angle about their historical past: “Many engineers are beneath the impression that the Germans invented the magnetic amplifier; really it’s an American invention. The Germans merely took our comparatively crude system, improved the effectivity and response time, decreased weight and bulk, broadened its subject of software, and handed it again to us.”

The U.S. area program additionally made in depth use of magnetic amplifiers due to their reliability. For instance, the
Redstone rocket, which launched Alan Shepard into area in 1961, used magnetic amplifiers. Within the Apollo missions to the moon throughout the 1960s and ’70s, magnetic amplifiers managed energy provides and fan blowers. Satellites of that period used magnetic amplifiers for sign conditioning, for present sensing and limiting, and for telemetry. Even the area shuttle used magnetic amplifiers to dim its fluorescent lights.

Magnetic amplifiers had been additionally utilized in Redstone rockets, just like the one proven right here behind astronauts John Glenn, Virgil Grissom, and Alan Shepard.Common Photos Group/Getty Photos

Magnetic amplifiers additionally discovered heavy use in industrial management and automation, with many merchandise containing them being marketed beneath such model names as Basic Electrical’s
Amplistat, CGS Laboratories’ Increductor, Westinghouse’s Cypak (cybernetic bundle), and Librascope’s Unidec (common resolution ingredient).

The magnetic supplies developed in Germany throughout the Second World Struggle had their largest postwar influence of all, although, on the pc business. Within the late 1940s, researchers instantly acknowledged the flexibility of the brand new magnetic supplies to retailer information. A round magnetic core may very well be magnetized counterclockwise or clockwise, storing a Zero or a 1. Having what’s referred to as a rectangular hysteresis loop ensured that the fabric would keep solidly magnetized in one in every of these states after energy was eliminated.

Researchers quickly constructed what was known as core reminiscence from dense grids of magnetic cores. And these technologists quickly switched from utilizing wound-metal cores to cores created from ferrite, a ceramic materials containing iron oxide. By the mid-1960s, ferrite cores had been stamped out by the billions as manufacturing prices dropped to a fraction of a cent per core.

However core reminiscence will not be the one place the place magnetic supplies had an affect on early digital computer systems. The primary era of these machines, beginning within the 1940s, computed utilizing vacuum tubes. These had been changed within the late 1950s with a second era primarily based on transistors, adopted by third-generation computer systems constructed from built-in circuits.

Transistors weren’t an apparent winner for early computer systems, and plenty of different alternate options had been developed, together with magnetic amplifiers.

However technological progress in computing wasn’t, in reality, this linear. Early transistors weren’t an apparent winner, and plenty of different alternate options had been developed. Magnetic amplifiers had been one in every of a number of largely forgotten computing applied sciences that fell between the generations.

That’s as a result of researchers within the early 1950s realized that magnetic cores couldn’t solely maintain information but additionally carry out logic capabilities. By placing a number of windings round a core, inputs may very well be mixed. A winding in the wrong way might inhibit different inputs, for instance. Complicated logic circuits may very well be carried out by connecting such cores collectively in numerous preparations.

In 1956, the
Sperry Rand Co. developed a high-speed magnetic amplifier known as the Ferractor, able to working at a number of megahertz. Every Ferractor was constructed by winding a dozen wraps of one-eighth-mil (about Three micrometers) Permalloy tape round a 0.1-inch (2.5-mm) nonmagnetic stainless-steel bobbin.

The Ferractor’s efficiency was as a result of outstanding thinness of this tape together with the tiny dimensions of the bobbin. Sperry Rand used the Ferractor in a navy laptop known as the Univac Magnetic Pc, also called the Air Power Cambridge Analysis Middle (AFCRC) laptop. This machine contained 1,500 Ferractors and 9,000 germanium diodes, in addition to a couple of transistors and vacuum tubes.

Sperry Rand later created enterprise computer systems primarily based on the AFCRC laptop: the
Univac Solid State (identified in Europe because the Univac Calculating Tabulator) adopted by the inexpensive STEP (Easy Transition Digital Processing) laptop. Though the Univac Strong State did not fully reside as much as its title—its processor used 20 vacuum tubes—it was reasonably in style, with lots of offered.

One other division of Sperry Rand constructed a pc known as
Bogart to assist with codebreaking on the U.S. Nationwide Safety Company. Followers of Casablanca and Key Largo can be upset to study that this laptop was named after the well-known New York Solar editor John Bogart. This comparatively small laptop earned that title as a result of it edited cryptographic information earlier than it was processed by the NSA’s bigger computer systems.

5 Bogart computer systems had been delivered to the NSA between 1957 and 1959. They employed a novel magnetic-amplifier circuit designed by
Seymour Cray, who later created the well-known Cray supercomputers. Reportedly, out of his dozens of patents, Cray was most proud of his magnetic-amplifier design.

Computer systems primarily based on magnetic amplifiers didn’t at all times work out so nicely, although. For instance, within the early 1950s, Swedish billionaire industrialist
Axel Wenner-Gren created a line of vacuum-tube computer systems, known as the ALWAC (Axel L. Wenner-Gren Computerized Pc). In 1956, he instructed the U.S. Federal Reserve Board that he might ship a magnetic-amplifier model, the ALWAC 800, in 15 months. After the Federal Reserve Board paid US $231,800, growth of the pc bumped into engineering difficulties, and the mission led to whole failure.

Advances in transistors throughout the 1950s led, after all, to the decline of computer systems utilizing magnetic amplifiers. However for a time, it wasn’t clear which know-how was superior. Within the mid-1950s, for instance, Sperry Rand was debating between magnetic amplifiers and transistors for the
Athena, a 24-bit laptop to regulate the Titan nuclear missile. Cray constructed two equal computer systems to match the applied sciences head-to-head: the Magstec (magnetic swap take a look at laptop) used magnetic amplifiers, whereas the Transtec (transistor take a look at laptop) used transistors. Though the Magstec carried out barely higher, it was changing into clear that transistors had been the wave of the longer term. So Sperry Rand constructed the Univac Athena laptop from transistors, relegating magazine amps to minor capabilities inside the pc’s energy provide.

In Europe, too, the transistor was battling it out with the magnetic amplifier. For instance, engineers at Ferranti, in the UK, developed magnetic–amplifier circuits for his or her computer systems. However they discovered that transistors offered extra dependable amplification, in order that they changed the magnetic amplifier with a transformer along side a transistor. They known as this circuit the Neuron as a result of it produced an output if the inputs exceeded a threshold, analogous to a organic neuron. The Neuron grew to become the center of Ferranti’s Sirius and Orion enterprise computer systems.

One other instance is the Polish EMAL-2 laptop of 1958, which used magnetic-core logic together with 100 vacuum tubes. This 34-bit laptop was Poland’s first really productive digital laptop. It was compact however sluggish, performing solely 150 or so operations per second.

And within the Soviet Union, the 15-bit LEM-1 computer from 1954 used 3,000 ferrite logical components (together with 16,000 selenium diodes). It might carry out 1,200 additions per second.

In France, magnetic amplifiers had been used within the
CAB 500 (Calculatrice Arithmétique Binaire 500), offered in 1960 for scientific and technical use by an organization known as Société d’Electronique et d’Automatisme (SEA). This 32-bit desk-size laptop used a magnetic logic ingredient known as the Symmag, together with transistors and a vacuum-tube energy provide. In addition to being programmed in Fortran, Algol, or SEA’s personal language, PAF (Programmation Automatique des Formules), the CAB 500 may very well be used as a desk calculator.

Some computer systems of this period used multiaperture cores with advanced shapes to implement logic capabilities. In 1959, engineers at Bell Laboratories developed a ladder-shaped magnetic ingredient known as
the Laddic, which carried out logic capabilities by sending alerts round totally different “rungs.” This system was later utilized in some nuclear-reactor security programs.

One other method alongside these traces was one thing known as the
Biax logic element—a ferrite dice with holes alongside two axes. One other was dubbed the transfluxor, which had two round openings. Round 1961, engineers on the Stanford Analysis Institute constructed the all-magnetic logic computer for the U.S. Air Power utilizing such multi-aperture magnetic gadgets. Doug Engelbart, who famously went on to invent the mouse and far of the fashionable laptop person interface, was a key engineer on this laptop.

Some computer systems of the time used transistors together with magnetic cores. The thought was to reduce the variety of then-expensive transistors. This method, known as core transistor logic (CTL), was used within the British
Elliott 803 laptop, a small system launched in 1959 with an uncommon 39-bit phrase size. The Burroughs D210 magnetic laptop of 1960, a compact laptop of simply 35 kilos (about 16 kilograms) designed for aerospace functions, additionally used core-transistor logic.

Core-transistor logic was significantly in style for area functions. An organization known as Di/An Controls produced a line of logic circuits and claimed that “most area autos are full of them.” The corporate’s Pico-Bit was a competing core-transistor-logic product, marketed in 1964 as “Your finest bit in area.” Early prototypes of NASA’s
Apollo Guidance Computer had been constructed with core transistor logic, however in 1962 the designers at MIT made a dangerous swap to built-in circuits.

Even some “absolutely transistorized” computer systems made use of magnetic amplifiers right here and there. The MIT
TX-2 of 1958 used them to regulate its tape-drive motors, whereas the IBM 7090, launched in 1959, and the favored IBM System/360 mainframes, launched in 1964, used magnetic amplifiers to manage their energy provides. Management Knowledge Corp.’s 160 minicomputer of 1960 used a magnetic amplifier in its console typewriter. Magnetic amplifiers had been too sluggish for the logic circuits within the Univac LARC supercomputer of 1960, however they had been used to drive its core reminiscence.

Within the 1950s, engineers within the U.S. Navy had known as magnetic amplifiers “a rising star” and one in every of “the marvels of postwar electronics.” As late as 1957, greater than 400 engineers attended a convention on magnetic amplifiers. However curiosity in these gadgets steadily declined throughout the 1960s when transistors and different semiconductors took over.

But lengthy after everybody figured that these gadgets had been destined for the mud heap of historical past, magazine amps discovered a brand new software. Within the mid-1990s, the
ATX normal for private computer systems required a fastidiously regulated 3.3-volt energy provide. It turned out that magnetic amplifiers had been a reasonable but environment friendly solution to management this voltage, making the magazine amp a key a part of most PC energy provides. As earlier than, this revival of magnetic amplifiers didn’t final: DC-DC regulators have largely changed magnetic amplifiers in fashionable energy provides.

All in all, the historical past of magnetic amplifiers spans a few century, with them changing into in style after which dying out a number of instances. You’d be exhausting pressed to discover a magazine amp in digital {hardware} produced as we speak, however possibly some new software—maybe for quantum computing or wind generators or electrical autos—will breathe life into them but once more.